It's an age old game played by rugby pundits in wondering how today's crop of players match up to past greats.
Now Tenby United fans have a chance to put it to the test by picking their 'silver' squad made up of those who have donned the famous red and black shirts of the Seasiders over the last 25 years.
You can pick your ideal 15 - tight and loose head props, hooker, locks, blind side and open side flankers, number eight, scrum half, outside half, centres wings and full back - from anyone who has played in these positions for Tenby from the1978 season to the present day.
If your team matches up with the team selected by a panel of former Tenby United greats and loyal supporters, then you could be in with a chance of winning a meal for two.
Team selection sheets, costing £1, are available at the ground during home games and from the clubhouse.
The silver squad will be unveiled at a special evening in Tenby United's Upper Frog Street clubhouse in March.