An ASH Wales survey found 53 per cent of smokers in Wales believe vaping is at least as harmful as smoking, as a new international study finds people who smoke now think worse of vaping than of cigarettes

More than half of smokers in Wales wrongly believe vaping is as harmful as smoking or worse, as a new international study warns that smoking is becoming more socially acceptable among people who smoke while vaping falls out of favour.

The study of almost 20,000 adults who smoke daily in England, the United States, Canada and Australia, published in the journal Nicotine & Tobacco Research on 16 November, found that between 2016 and 2022 the share with a negative opinion of smoking fell from 52.1 per cent to 43.0 per cent, while the share with a negative opinion of vaping rose from 32.8 per cent to 49.1 per cent. By 2022, more of them took a negative view of vaping than of smoking.

Wales was not part of the study, but a survey for the charity ASH Wales suggests the same misunderstanding about vaping is widespread in Wales. The YouGov survey of 1,119 adults in Wales, carried out between 18 February and 19 March and published in the autumn, found that 54 per cent of adults who had heard of vapes wrongly believed vaping was as harmful as smoking or more harmful, including 53 per cent of current smokers. Only 28 per cent said vapes were less harmful.

ASH Wales said the share of adults holding that belief was around 33 per cent in 2022 and 24 per cent in 2016, although the differences between survey years have not been tested for statistical significance.

Public Health Wales says vaping is substantially less harmful than smoking but is not risk-free, and that children and people who do not smoke should not vape.

Smoking caused an estimated average of 3,845 deaths a year among adults aged 35 and over in Wales between 2020 and 2022, according to Public Health Wales. A Public Health Wales report published in July put the cost of smoking to Wales at £1.56 billion a year, counting health and social care, lost productivity and environmental costs.

By health board, the yearly cost was put at £316m in Aneurin Bevan, £300m in Betsi Cadwaladr, £278m in Cwm Taf Morgannwg, £250m in Cardiff and Vale, £195m in Swansea Bay, £173m in Hywel Dda and £50m in Powys, based on 2022/23 figures.

The Welsh Government's tobacco strategy aims to bring adult smoking down to 5 per cent or less by 2030.

The study's lead author, Dr Giang Vu of the University of Queensland, said, "Vaping, though not harmless, poses fewer health risks than smoking. A weakening of disapproval for smoking may reduce the motivation to quit among people at highest risk. A growing disapproval of vaping may discourage people who smoke from switching to a less harmful alternative."

When the survey was published, Suzanne Cass, chief executive of ASH Wales, said, "Vaping is not risk-free, and children and people who do not smoke should not start. But adults who smoke need to know that switching completely to vaping is less harmful than continuing to smoke and can help them quit."

Shane Margereson, founder of Ecigone, a five-time award-winning UK online vape shop, said, "When half the smokers in Wales think a vape is as bad as a cigarette, a lot of them will simply carry on smoking. That's what worries me about these figures. Vaping isn't risk-free and it isn't for anyone who doesn't smoke, but for an adult who does, the NHS and Public Health Wales are both clear that it's far less harmful than cigarettes."

What the study did not show

The international study looked at attitudes rather than behaviour, and its authors said it did not measure quitting or switching of products or establish cause and effect. It covered adults who smoke daily, its latest figures are from 2022, and it did not include Wales. The Welsh figures come from the separate ASH Wales survey.

Free NHS support to stop smoking is available across Wales from Help Me Quit on 0800 085 2219.