Parents and guardians whose children attend one of Tenby’s primary schools, have voiced concerns that Pembrokeshire County Council has already made its mind up about the future of the facility following a meeting this week where they said they were “ambushed” with the news that the school is moving permanently to the Ysgol Greenhill site opposite on Heywood Lane, with plans to demolish the current building, which was only constructed 10 years ago - already in the pipeline.
A public consultation on Pembrokeshire County Council’s proposal to discontinue Tenby Church in Wales Voluntary Controlled School; and the seaside town’s Ysgol Greenhill secondary school - with a view to establish a new 3-19 Community School for the locality, got underway back in September, closing earlier this month on November 3.
At its meeting on December 12, 2025, Pembrokeshire County Council considered a report of the School Modernisation Working Group which outlined the findings of a review of education provision in the Tenby area.
In particular, the review considered the extent of surplus school places in the area, set against a significant decline in the pupil population.
The decision of Council was as follows - that the Director of Education be authorised to commence statutory consultation on establishing a new 3-19 school - split site initially, but as part of future Sustainable Communities for Learning investment to rebuild/extend Greenhill site, or on a new site.
Tenby VC School, a 3–11 English-medium primary school with an additional Learning Resource Centre (LRC) provision, was built in 2016.
However, just a few years after its build, there were reports of water ingress. At the November 2025 Cabinet meeting of Pembrokeshire Council, members received a report detailing the findings of a feasibility study, with a favoured option of the replacement of the entire roof, backing tenders for the works being sought.
It was warned there would need to be a “a comprehensive decant strategy” for pupils to go elsewhere while the works took place.
Members were also asked to consider which decant strategies are to be considered for detailed feasibility, in order to enable the roof replacement works to take place.
Options included: decanting the whole school to Saundersfoot CP and Stepaside Schools while retaining Tenby VC as a separate entity at a cost of some £0.5m a year; distribute Tenby VC pupils across multiple local schools across the wider Tenby cluster; decant to nearby comprehensive Greenhill School which currently has 302 surplus places; establish a modular village at the northern boundary of Greenhill School, a self-contained modular village adjacent to Heywood Lane, comprising nine classrooms and associated facilities for Tenby VC; and a hybrid model combining the modular village and Greenhill accommodation.
PCC’s Deputy Leader, Cllr Paul Miller stated at the time, that there were, in effect, two options for the building - to replace the roof “or don’t, and effectively abandon that site”.
“A roof completely failing on a 10-year-old building is completely bad news, but we have 180 children being educated in a building that is no longer fit for purpose, and we have to get on with it,” he remarked.
Now, following a meeting held this week on November 18, parents have disputed whether decisions that are being made behind the scenes by the Local Authority, were actually factored into the public consultation.
One parent said that they felt that Pembrokeshire Council were “steamrolling” proposals in a manner which “intentionally minimises scrutiny, lacks transparency and pays little regard to the education” of local children.
One parent has subsequently written to PCC’s Director of Education, Steven Richards-Downes, and Deputy Leader Cllr Paul Miller voicing concerns, stating: “I am writing following yesterday’s meeting, which I attended, where the Council said that Tenby VC School will close for roof repair and move permanently to the Greenhill site in about 18 months, that the roof cost is about twice the cost of moving, and that the current building would be demolished.
“I want to be clear that is not what the consultation document told families. I ask the County Council to answer the questions below and to re-consult before it takes this proposal further.
“I have compared the consultation document (September 2026) with the Cabinet reports of 3 November 2025 and 1 June 2026.
“I accept that the roof project is a separate decision. But the consultation document relies on the state of the building, and on relocation, so the facts behind both matter to the proposal.
“It also calculates surplus places on the current school buildings, not on the position once Tenby VC has moved to the Greenhill site.
“The proposed permanent move to the Greenhill site fundamentally changes the status quo, to align with one of the alternative options described in the consultation document,” they continued.
“The roof is a safety matter and I am not asking the Council to delay the repair.
“My concern is that families were asked to respond on one set of facts, and the Council now describes another.
“The permanent move to the Greenhill site and the proposed discontinuation of both schools would fall within a narrow window.
“I believe the combined disruption will materially affect the education and welfare of the children, parents and staff, and the consultation should take that impact into account,” they added.
Another parent contacted the Observer with their concerns, stating: “I believe there are serious questions that need asking about Pembrokeshire Council’s decision-making, the transparency of its consultation processes and whether the people of Tenby are being given a genuine opportunity to influence the future of education in their community.
“I am particularly concerned about what appears to be a contradiction in the Council’s approach.
“The Council is consulting on proposals to merge Tenby VC School and Ysgol Greenhill into a new 3–19 school.
“At the same time, it is recommending the permanent relocation of Tenby VC School onto the Greenhill site because of the required roof replacement works,” they continued, stating that information provided to parents appears to confirm that:
- The recommended option is to permanently relocate Tenby VC School to the Ysgol Greenhill site.
- The existing Tenby VC building would eventually be demolished following relocation.
- The target date for completing the relocation is June 2028.
- If the existing school building underwent roof replacement, pupils might not be able to return until at least October 2029.
- The Council intends to proceed with detailed design, procurement and relocation works.
Yet, in the same document, the Council states: ‘This accommodation proposal is separate from the consultation on creating a new 3-19 school. A decision on school accommodation does not determine the outcome of that separate process.’
“I find this statement extremely difficult to reconcile with the practical implications of the recommendation,” the parent continued.
“How can a decision to permanently relocate a school onto another school’s site, potentially followed by the demolition of its existing building, have no bearing on the future options for a proposed new 3–19 school involving those very schools?
“Even if these are technically separate administrative processes, surely the physical, financial and operational consequences of one decision have the potential to affect the other?” they continued.

They also said that they were concerned about whether the consultation process has been “genuinely meaningful” if decisions with potentially permanent consequences are being progressed before the wider future of education in Tenby has even been settled.
They added: “The Welsh Government’s School Organisation Code 2026 places importance on meaningful consultation while proposals remain at a formative stage, with proper consideration of alternatives and the responses received.
“I believe it is reasonable for residents to expect the Council to demonstrate that these principles have been followed in the context of both proposals.
“This is about more than two school buildings. It is about the future of education in Tenby and the surrounding community.
“Parents and residents deserve transparency. They deserve to understand why these decisions are being made, what alternatives have genuinely been considered, what the long-term consequences will be and whether the options presented to them are still genuinely available.”
The matter concerning the temporary options for Tenby VC School are set to be discussed further by PCC’s Cabinet on November 30.
Earlier this month, The Diocese of St Davids formally objected to Pembrokeshire County Council's proposals to close Tenby Church in Wales Voluntary Controlled School and Ysgol Greenhill School, calling for a fresh consultation that gives equal consideration to retaining Church in Wales education in the seaside town.
In its formal response, the Diocese raised concerns about the fairness of the consultation process; the potential loss of faith-based education; and the financial implications of establishing a new 3–19 community school.
While supporting the ambition to modernise education in Tenby, the Diocese said that it believes “credible alternatives” exist that would deliver a new school while preserving Church in Wales provision.
The Diocese has highlighted that the Council's own 121-page consultation document identifies alternative Voluntary Controlled (VC) and Voluntary Aided (VA) models, but gives them comparatively limited consideration.

A spokesperson on behalf of the Diocese of St Davids said: "We fully support the ambition to provide modern, high-quality education for children and young people in Tenby. However, we strongly believe this can be achieved without sacrificing the Church in Wales education that has been an important part of the town for generations.
"Our objection is not to educational improvement, but to the unnecessary removal of established Church in Wales provision when credible alternatives exist.
"Parents, pupils and the wider community deserve a fair and transparent consultation in which every realistic option is properly explored. We do not believe the current process has achieved that,” they added.
The Diocese has also highlighted the potential significant financial advantages of a new Voluntary Aided school, which could attract 85% Welsh Government capital funding compared with the standard 65% rate for a community school.
Based on comparisons with recent school developments, the Diocese estimates the Council's contribution towards a new community school could exceed £22 million, with a Voluntary Aided model potentially reducing the burden on local taxpayers by millions of pounds.
The Diocese has further questioned why the structural problems affecting Tenby VC School, ten years after it opened in 2016, have become a driving factor in proposals that would remove Church in Wales education from the town.
Pembrokeshire County Council has been contacted for comment.






Comments
We've recently changed our login process. If you have an account for commenting, you will need to re-register on the login window.
This article has no comments yet. Be the first to leave a comment.